Developer ToolsFeaturedProgrammingSoftware Development

Writing Custom memmove Functions: When and How

3 Mins read
Writing Custom memmove Functions: When and How
C programming illustration representing custom memmove functions

Writing a Custom C memmove: Safe Copies for Overlapping Memory

Moving bytes around sounds simple—until the source and destination overlap. Copy in the wrong direction and you can overwrite data before it has been read. C’s standard memmove handles that case, but understanding its logic is useful when implementing a minimal runtime, learning low-level memory operations, or targeting a specialized environment.

This guide explains when a custom implementation makes sense, how to write one without a temporary buffer, and what to test before relying on it. In production, prefer the standard library unless you have a clear, measured reason to replace it.

What memmove Guarantees

The C standard library declares memmove in <string.h>. It copies n characters (treated as bytes) from the source object to the destination object. The result must be as if the original source bytes were first copied into a temporary, non-overlapping array and then written to the destination.

That “as if” rule is what makes overlap safe. Unlike memcpy, whose source and destination regions must not overlap, memmove preserves the original bytes even when the ranges intersect. Its return value is the destination pointer.

When Should You Write a Custom memmove?

Most programs should call the library function. Compilers and C libraries can select optimized implementations for the target architecture, so a hand-written loop is not automatically faster. A custom version may be justified when:

  • You are building a freestanding or minimal runtime without the required library implementation.
  • You are studying pointer arithmetic, byte copying, or how overlap affects correctness.
  • You have a specialized platform requirement and can verify it with appropriate tests and benchmarks.
  • You need a clearly defined wrapper or instrumentation layer for a project-specific purpose.

For latency-sensitive systems, predictable behavior matters as much as speed; see memmove in Real-Time Applications. For large data transfers, architecture and workload can change the performance picture, as discussed in memmove in High-Performance Computing.

A Simple Overlap-Safe Implementation

The key is to copy forward when the destination begins before the source, and backward when the destination begins inside the source range. This avoids overwriting bytes that still need to be read.

#include <stddef.h>

void *my_memmove(void *dest, const void *src, size_t n)
{
    unsigned char *d = dest;
    const unsigned char *s = src;

    if (n == 0 || d == s)
        return dest;

    if (d < s) {
        for (size_t i = 0; i < n; ++i)
            d[i] = s[i];
    } else {
        for (size_t i = n; i != 0; --i)
            d[i - 1] = s[i - 1];
    }

    return dest;
}

This example illustrates the usual direction strategy, but it is not a fully portable implementation as written: relational comparisons such as d < s are only defined by C for pointers into the same array object (or one past it). Comparing unrelated object pointers this way can therefore invoke undefined behavior. A production-quality implementation must use an approach supported by its target and C implementation, or simply use the standard library.

Understand the Pointer and Range Requirements

For a valid call with n > 0, the source and destination must each refer to accessible regions of at least n bytes. The standard function does not provide general validation for invalid pointers or out-of-bounds ranges. A custom routine cannot safely check arbitrary pointers to prove that those conditions hold.

When the ranges are known to be within the same array, their order can guide the copy direction. If they do not overlap, either direction works. If the destination starts within the source range at a higher address, copying backward protects the unread source bytes; otherwise, copying forward is safe.

Why a Temporary Buffer Is Usually Not the Best Fix

A temporary buffer is an easy way to explain the “as if copied through a temporary array” guarantee, but allocating one for every call is often impractical. It can use substantial extra memory, fail to allocate, or exhaust a stack if created as a variable-length array. The standard guarantee describes the result; it does not require an actual temporary buffer.

A direction-based implementation avoids that extra storage. However, correct pointer ordering is subtle in portable C, and highly tuned library implementations may use architecture-specific techniques. Treat a simple loop as a learning example, not an automatic replacement for memmove.

Testing a Custom Memory-Move Function

Test the cases that expose overlap bugs, not only copies between separate arrays. Useful checks include:

  • A zero-length copy and a copy where source and destination are identical.
  • Non-overlapping ranges, with the destination both before and after the source.
  • Overlapping ranges where the destination begins inside the source, and where it begins before the source.
  • Small and larger byte counts, including boundary cases in the surrounding code.

Compare results against the standard memmove using valid buffers, and use compiler warnings and memory-safety tools where available. Do not test invalid pointers by expecting the function to recover: such calls do not have defined behavior. For platform-specific details, consult Cross-Platform Behavior of memmove.

Conclusion

A custom memmove is most valuable as a way to understand C memory operations or meet a specific runtime constraint—not as a default performance upgrade. Its defining requirement is overlap safety: copy in the direction that prevents writes from destroying source bytes that have not yet been read. Be cautious about pointer comparisons, validate the assumptions your environment guarantees, and test both overlap directions. For ordinary applications, the standard library remains the clearest and most dependable choice.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *